In some ways, reading The Ocean at the End of the Lane was similar to other Neil Gaiman works I read before and after—that sensation of being held in thrall, dreamlike or drunkenness, of racing along and being slightly out of control. At the end of a book, I would shake it off and think, wow, that was a great read. But not so with Ocean. I distinctly recall finishing it, the light elation of completion washed away by a deeper disturbance. I remember holding the paperback, unsure if I should put it on a shelf with others I mean to reread, or fling it at the wall in disgust. I couldn’t really define what about it set so many alarm bells ringing in my head—just that it had.
I look back in my catalog of books I’ve read, dated and rated for how much I like them*, and see it listed in 2014, no stars. A neutral rating. That tracks.
I, like so many others, viewed Gaiman as a lovable, floppy-haired, modern wizard of words. At least half-fae, most likely. What else could explain it? I bought multiple audiobooks of his works to hear his melodious elocution breathing life into those words, lulling me into that dreamlike state. Holding me in thrall. And so much of what I’ve just written made so much more sense upon reading the damning article that came out this week. (I can’t in good conscience recommend ANYONE read it, because it is so dark and vile, but if you, like me, feel you really need to know, here you go. CW: graphic depictions of sexual assault, manipulation, and it will be seared into your brain forever.)
All I can say about the article, having read it, is that all of my deeper, somewhat-inexplicable feelings about his works fell into place, and fit a broader pattern of behavior and intent. I haven’t read some of his stories others have cited that show even more blatantly his true nature, but what I read was enough to be wary when the first allegations dropped last summer, and happily I had sold nearly all of his books two days before the article hit. (Missed one; off the shelf it goes.)
The lesson is old but stays true: don’t idolize authors, or artists, or really any person. Everyone has human failings—granted, some are vastly more disappointing than others. (See also: JK Rowling.) I don’t necessarily agree with “don’t meet your heroes” because sometimes people really are as they present themselves to be (and thank goodness! there has to be something GOOD and TRUE in this world still, jfc.) The moment you put someone on a pedestal, they start to wobble. Cherish the creative works that gave you something new in yourself, but don’t worship the creators.
Burn your idols.
*What, you don’t like to know when you read something and whether or not you liked it?